Recently, there has been a lot of information on the internet about base oils, their origins, extraction types, synthesis technologies, including hydrocracking and the assumption that motor oils cannot be fully synthetic. In this article, together with Invent Group, we will learn how mineral, semi-synthetic, and synthetic oils differ on a molecular level, what additive packages affect, and how to choose among Shell Helix motor oil types:
Shell Helix Ultra - premium synthetic based on Pureplus technology.
Shell Helix Extra - fully synthetic oils from petroleum origins.
Shell Helix HX7, HX6 - semi-synthetic oils.
Base oils as the foundation of lubricants
Any motor oil consists of a base oil and a functional additive package. The difference in base oil is not only in the method of production but also in the degree of homogeneity and control over the molecular composition. Base oils are divided into groups: I, II, III, IV, V.
1. Groups I and II. Obtained from oil through purification, dewaxing, or hydrocracking; after processing, it remains a complex mixture of different hydrocarbon molecules.
2. Group III. Obtained from oil or natural gas through hydrocracking (deep processing of hydrocarbon feedstock at high temperatures and pressures in the presence of hydrogen).
3. Group IV. These are PAOs - polyalphaolefins, obtained through chemical synthesis.
Mineral oils: production features and applications
Mineral base oils are produced from crude oil through refining, distillation, and subsequent technical treatment. They have a wider distribution of molecular structures and change viscosity more significantly with temperature. Under prolonged thermal stress, they are more prone to oxidation and the formation of aging products. But this does not mean that they are bad. If the specifications specifically mention mineral oil for the engine, the choice should be among mineral oils.
For which types of engines mineral oil is most suitable
The appropriateness of using 'mineral oil' is determined by the manufacturer's requirements:
- engines for which the design specifies the relevant SAE classes and older operating specifications;
- parts of older generation vehicles;
- equipment for which the manufacturer does not require modern low-viscosity or Low SAPS oils.
Synthetic oils: technology and maximum protection
In synthetic base oil, there is a lower distribution of molecular structures and more controlled properties. This is especially important for modern engines due to:
- high local temperatures;
- turbocharging;
- frequent start-stop cycles;
- high specific loads;
- reduction of working clearances;
- use of DPF, GPF systems, and catalysts;
- transition of some automakers to low viscosity classes 0W-20.
There is a common myth that synthetic oil eats away seals in older engines. This arose because old engines may already have hardened and cracked seals, worn gaskets, mechanical defects, and significant deposits around sealing zones. If the engine has a mechanical problem, the condition of the seals should be evaluated separately, and the motor oil chosen according to the technical requirements of the engine.
Why synthetic oil retains properties at extreme temperatures
During cold starts, the oil must quickly circulate through the system and reach the friction pairs. At high temperatures, on the contrary, it must retain sufficient viscosity and lubricating film. This describes viscosity - the resistance of a liquid to flow.
Thermal stability - the ability of the lubricant to resist destruction and undesirable changes in properties due to high temperatures. High thermal stability is especially relevant for turbocharged engines, city driving with frequent starts and stops, and prolonged driving under load. Shell motor oils can be fully synthetic and designed for operation at both very low and high temperatures and under heavy operating conditions.
Semi-Synthetic as a balance of price and characteristics
Semi-synthetic motor oils are products that combine mineral and synthetic base components. This combination allows for higher performance characteristics than using only mineral base oil. This is the principle on which part of the Shell Helix HX7 lineup is based. Semi-synthetic oil can be a rational solution for engines that do not require modern fully synthetic low-viscosity products but have higher requirements than the basic mineral formula can provide.
Rules for choosing the type of oil according to the manufacturer's requirements
- Determine the necessary SAE viscosity grade.
- Check the required API or ACEA specification.
- Find the specific approval from the automaker, if available.
- Consider the type of engine and exhaust gas purification systems.
- Among products that meet these requirements, assess base type, change interval, price, and operating conditions.
5W-30 by itself does not indicate whether the product is suitable for a specific BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen, or Renault.
How to correctly read approvals and markings on the canister
Before choosing whether mineral or synthetic oil will be in the engine, it’s worth distinguishing:
- Viscosity by SAE (5W-30, 0W-20) - it describes low and high-temperature rheological characteristics.
- Operational category API (SN, SP) - they define the set of tests and requirements that the lubricant must meet.
- ACEA class (C3, C6) - defines the set of tests for engine designs and ecological systems.
- OEM (VW 504 00/507 00, MB 229.51, BMW LL-04, etc.) - specific approvals from the automaker, or their official approvals.
Mineral, semi-synthetic, and synthetic oils primarily differ in the technology of obtaining and properties of the base components. Synthetic bases offer broader possibilities for creating products with high stability of properties across a wide temperature range, while mineral and semi-synthetic products remain relevant where they meet the technical requirements of a specific engine.
